Top Picks

Explore the most popular Sheetz MTO Top Picks menu items, including burgers, snacks, chicken, and customer favorites loved for flavor and value.

image 2026 05 08T181528.236

Made To Order Burger

$5.99+ | 250 cals

image 2026 05 08T181544.554

Made To Order Sh’tacked Burger

$7.49+ | 664 cals

image 2026 05 08T181559.637

Classic Sampler

$6.49+ | 0 cals

image 2026 05 08T181613.505

Shwingz

$7.39+ | 533 cals

image 2026 05 08T181626.804

Made To Order – Steak

$5.69+ | 371 cals

image 2026 05 08T181641.656

Italian

$5.69+ | 337 cals

image 2026 05 08T181704.016

Turkey Sub

$4.89+ | 300 cals

image 2026 05 08T181719.036

Made To Order Hot Dog

$1.00+ | 140 cals